|
Post by YOLO on Oct 17, 2014 9:31:05 GMT
Hi everybody! I think that Tally can become pretty if she thinks that she's ugly. You don't have to live with a body you don't like if you are ready to change it.33 However, she must first thinks of the consequences. Therefore, when she is older, the plastic surgery she did before might turn bad. 55 In addition, I think that if you do plastic surgery one time, you can easily do it an other time, even if you don't need it. It might become like a drug! 87 Furthermore, I think that everybody has one's own beauty. If you do too much plastic surgery, you could become ugly. It's like make-up. If you put too much make up on your face, you could be ugly too. 125 In order to conclude, in my opinion, Tally shouldn't become pretty because she is already pretty, as Shay said.
|
|
jade
New Member
Posts: 4
|
Post by jade on Oct 17, 2014 9:31:08 GMT
smizby i really disagree with you, first of all if you are ugly you must accept what you are and not try to be different !!!!! I AGREE WITH YOU but in her world they have a diferent way to think we are not in our world of compassion !!!
Oh God xDD Well it seems we have to end up here ! xx
|
|
|
Post by Benedicte on Oct 17, 2014 9:31:20 GMT
Hello everyone,
According to me, I think that Tally ought not to become pretty. Firstly, her body is still changing that is to say that the surgery may not succeed and she might suffer because of it. Even if the society in which she lives is ruled by extreme beauty standards, turning to plastic surgery is not compalsury. What I mean is that she can choose to stay as gorgeous as she currently is.
Secondly, to my mind, she doesn't have to become like all the other girls to be happy as she could stay with Shay who is her true best friend.
Eventually, in my opinion, she has to accept who she truely is, which means that she has to learn to respect herself and to like the way she looks.
In a nutshell,in this society in which everyone does whatever is necessary to become perfect, anyone who is different becomes unique which means that the people who didn't turn to plastic surgery are more beautiful
|
|
|
Post by Op1802 on Oct 17, 2014 9:31:46 GMT
Last week we worked about a book, called Uglies. I think about different way for the question "should Tally become pretty ?"
On the one hand, Tally can become pretty, however I don't think this way is possible: from my point of view, Tally has to create a sort of "revolution". To me that's the goal of this book. If she becomes pretty, she'll be just like the other girls, and this is no interesting. So let's me explain an other way of this book.
On the other hand, Tally doesn't become pretty, I suppose: Is the operation of plastic surgery miss, or is Tally's best friend convinces her ? I don't know exactly, but even if she's not pretty, Tally goes to Pretty Town. All the girls are looking for her, because they are beautiful, they follow a trend and they fit in a group. Tally's the contrary. And it's because she's different, that she'll create a reaction: maybe the beautiful girls will be listening to Tally, and they'll realized that they don't have to look like Barbies for having a good life and being "fashion".
After that, the operation isn't an obligation anymore. The girls and the boys who are sixteen years old can have the choice. Pretty Town doesn't exist anymore, and everybody live in the same world. Beauty hasn't importance and they live in peace, because they realized that they haven't to wear stylish clothes if they want to have loads of friends. An ugly isn't a loser anymore.
Thanks for reading my comment. I hope you to like this book !
|
|
|
Post by Tall Pony on Oct 17, 2014 9:32:01 GMT
Every days , every where , people who are too fat or too uglie are victim of mockery , this is a shape of discrimination ,so to them plastic surgery is a very good solution ! However , i agree that we are not obliged to do this but if we are not or you was not victim of mockery you can't understand what they they undergo.
|
|
|
Post by C'est pas moi on Oct 17, 2014 9:32:21 GMT
I'm agree with Zelda. They live in a dictatorship so they have to do what the Master say. She is 16 and when we are 16, we can't break a dictatorship with all his power. If i was living in this world, the question will be quickly answered
|
|
|
Post by lulu02 on Oct 17, 2014 9:32:41 GMT
I understand Tally but I think plastic surgery is too dangerous and she is too young to do a choice like this. She is too immature and be influence by other people.
|
|
|
Post by tris1O on Oct 17, 2014 9:32:54 GMT
:)I agree with rodrigo29 because plastic surgery is dangerous so be carefull Tally you don't need this but if you want become pretty I think its not good decisions, if you follow trend, you make up (6 time a day)like girl our generation you can be beautiful and you are too young for plastic surgery maybe in the futur you can be pretty!! To conclude Tally, do what you want but pay attention, think about your decision, look at what we have posted but to my mind its more cleaver dont to use plastic surgery be normal, and live your life with your physic
|
|
|
Post by Small pony on Oct 17, 2014 9:33:07 GMT
I disagree with you XxdarkjeankevinxX because due to being as everybody we think as everybody, thus nobody can not think, it is even what says Shay. And exactly for me, have to think of this question so early in its life it is not very good becauuse we can regret it all the life.
|
|
|
Post by xXdarkjeankevinXx on Oct 17, 2014 9:33:23 GMT
Alexandre I disagree with you because they are all the same so there in nothing in the eyes of the beholder , he can't judge !
|
|
|
Post by AzianSWAAGdu75020 on Oct 17, 2014 9:33:34 GMT
Hello Guys This novel is so funny, I'm crazy about Scott Westerfeld's books. From my point of view, Tally shouldn't become pretty. On the one hand, I think she is a beautiful girl maybe she has some complexe ( like her nose) but it's not a reason to turn plastic surgery. Plastic surgery is so STUPID...please ,promise me NEVER make it. I agree with Tally's best friend. She said Pretty "all look the same." or " We're not freaks. We're normal." Therefore Tally thinks being a pretty is "Like being an adult." On the other hand even if Tally is a young teenager she's not mature. She must grow up and forgets this trend. In the end, To me being pretty means being depreved of one's freedom Thanks for reading XOXO
|
|
|
Post by lili03 on Oct 17, 2014 9:33:57 GMT
Hello! I agree with you "Humans aren't Barbie dolls" !Plastic surgery is not good for health, Tally can find a man without looking perfect...But maybe she should live her city because the pressure must be very important.
|
|
|
Post by Annanas on Oct 17, 2014 9:34:08 GMT
so I think that Tally sould be herself and assumes her body, but she will have to take important decisions that she would not be able to change in the future.
|
|
|
Post by Alexandre Piel on Oct 17, 2014 9:34:25 GMT
Guillaume I disagree the fact that Tally Has to become pretty because it can be dangerous for her and everybody are what they are so ...
|
|
|
Post by Yz125 on Oct 17, 2014 9:34:55 GMT
I don't understand the people who wants to become pretty, because I prefer stay ugly to do plastic surgery. After surgery you can regret you're act. But I desagree with Jade because plastic surgery is not for idiots. For exemple an accident you will be happy to repar your body. In conclusion I think that she couldn't become pretty.
|
|