|
Post by TristanHerskovits on Oct 17, 2014 9:26:28 GMT
In her town you are grown up to become pretty, you can't choose: -In one hand, she become pretty, she go to Prettytown, she is happy, but she become stupid and she agree with the dictatorship of her town. -In the other hand, she leave her town, she lose all what her have and she become alone.
But Shay want Tally to not become pretty, concluding Tally can become pretty or she can follow Shay to escape of her town. Finally, I think she choose to realise her dream and she don't follow Shay.
|
|
|
Post by Yz125 on Oct 17, 2014 9:26:50 GMT
In my opinion, I think that Tally should stay normal. Because if everybody become pretty, they will look like Barbie girls. If she does plastic surgery, she will not be herself anymore. On one hand, if she is ugly, she hasn't got a group of beautiful people, but in the other hand she stays natural.
|
|
|
Post by Clemrock3 on Oct 17, 2014 9:27:06 GMT
Hi !!!
As a general rule, people want to be like they wanna be. However, people don't like being alone and have no friends. Thus, few persons are going to change their mind to aim at being in the band and follow the trends not to be out of the society.
From my point of view, Tally is in the second case. It means that she will turn to plastic surgery just not to be out of the society. Actually, she doesn't think like her best friend, Shay, who thinks that these "Barbies Dolls" from "BeautyLand", have no brain and are so boring. On the one hand, her friend tries to convince her not to consult a surgeon. Shay says that they could run away and not to finish empty-brained. On the other hand, Tally thinks about her future and knows that pretty girls succeed even if they are stupid.
In short, I think that Tally is gonna turn to plastic surgery and become pretty instead of staying in Uglies's world in order to be accepted by the society and succeed her future.
|
|
|
Post by anoushkaa15 on Oct 17, 2014 9:27:17 GMT
I also think that she has to assume her body and there's always an other alternative to plastic surgery such as make up or doing sport, because she is too young to do plastic surgery and I don't believe that she really knows what she would have to do after her plastic surgery. That's why, as far as I am concerned, I think that she has to think a little more before taking her decision. To conclued,it's up to her to decide what she wants to do in her life. I really agree with Annanas because I think Tally should accept her body even if he has some flaws.
|
|
|
Post by Boucledoriane on Oct 17, 2014 9:27:28 GMT
tris10: Sorry but it's imposible to meet nice boys in the street...
|
|
jade
New Member
Posts: 4
|
Post by jade on Oct 17, 2014 9:27:49 GMT
I think that Tally should become pretty because that will be very dificult for her to accept to live like an UGLY, in fact all her life she thought that becoming pretty was her dream but her best friend just decide to brake her dream. Shay is allowed to think that she have to leave the town wherever she just can't force her friend to come with her. So on the on hand Tally brake a friendship but realise her dream but on the other hand she can keep a friendship but she will never realise her dream to become PRETTY ! it's a tough choice and just Tally got the answer... Nah, sorry Sammy, but I disagree with you. Tally isn't really "ugly". So now you're ugly when you don't look like a doll ? She just doesn't have to follow the idiots who think that they're just one way to be pretty. And Shay is just smarter than her, admit that. She doesn't force Tally, anyway.
|
|
|
Post by Mister M on Oct 17, 2014 9:28:28 GMT
I think Tally shouldn't become pretty. I'm going to explain why. To my mind, it's no use to her to have plastic surgery. Because, she can't become beautiful because in this world, everybody is beautiful. So, if she has plastic surgery, she just looks the same as other people, she isn't "special" in the bright side of the word. Furthermore, I think, if everybody looks the same and you too, no one is here to say "Oh, you are pretty !" : in a word, no one see you. But she can also make a plastic surgery, it's to her to decide what she wants to become. She also have to know if she is really horrible. From my mind, no because Scott Westerfield explains in his book that she is normal ("In a world of extreme-beauty, anybody normal is ugly"). To conclude, I think it's not to me to decide what she wants, but "The beauty is in the eyes of the beholder" says someone. Me ( + de 150 mots)
|
|
|
Post by Etienne on Oct 17, 2014 9:28:44 GMT
Boucledoriane, s when you are uglie you are sad? that is because we live in a world based on looks : It is horrible no ?!
|
|
|
Post by Guillaume on Oct 17, 2014 9:28:55 GMT
I think that Tally should become pretty because that will be very dificult for her to accept to live like an UGLY, in fact all her life she thought that becoming pretty was her dream but her best friend just decide to brake her dream. Shay is allowed to think that she have to leave the town wherever she just can't force her friend to come with her. So on the on hand Tally brake a friendship but realise her dream but on the other hand she can keep a friendship but she will never realise her dream to become PRETTY ! it's a tough choice and just Tally got the answer... Hello Smizby, I totally agree with you, Tally is friendly but her dream to be pretty and do party every days is stronger than her friendship.
And for react to the small pony's post, i agree with you but in tally's mind become pretty is fun and stay ugly is horrible.
|
|
|
Post by smizby on Oct 17, 2014 9:29:06 GMT
smizby i really disagree with you, first of all if you are ugly you must accept what you are and not try to be different !!!!! I AGREE WITH YOU but in her world they have a diferent way to think we are not in our world of compassion !!!
|
|
|
Post by xXdarkjeankevinXx on Oct 17, 2014 9:29:48 GMT
it could be very hard to accept for some people like Tally
|
|
|
Post by Alexandre Piel on Oct 17, 2014 9:30:00 GMT
As far as I am concerned I think that Tally shouldn't become pretty because to me she is already beauty, so Tally needn't it. Even if she was ugly I will say to her that it is not very important because the more important is her personality. To my mind we are like we are and we can't be an other person: everybody is special. In addition the plastic surgery can be dangerous for her body. But maybe she feels bad thus the plastic surgery can be good for her.So she has to pay attention and be sure before making her decision. We aren't in a dictatorship, she had the choice and it is not to me to take her decision. In a word she just has to make what well he seem. I can just say: "the beauty is in the eyes of the beholder".
|
|
|
Post by Annanas on Oct 17, 2014 9:30:19 GMT
There's a fact that I don't understand: where is Tally going to live? because it will be easier to live in Pretty Town because she doesn't have to worry about what she have to eat or tings like that. whereas , maybe if she doesn't do the operation she will have a really hard life and be poor
|
|
|
Post by Alexandre P on Oct 17, 2014 9:30:36 GMT
Hello ! To my mind Tally should not become pretty, because maybe she feels she is ugly, but she is only fifteen, and she will change in two or three years. So, I think she is too young to turn to plastic surgery, whereas if she was twenty it could be ok. To me, you can be not beautiful, and happy. We should not forgot that plastic surgery can be dangerous. And, you can be pretty or beautiful without being a Barbie girl. But in the ugly book, if you aren't pretty you are loser, it is a bit the same in the real life . But as far as I'm conserved, I think if you have too much plastic surgery you aren't yourself anymore. Finally I think some people really have to turn to plastic surgery, for example people who had an accident. To conclude, I think teenagers like Tally shouldn't have plastic surgery because they are too young.
Thanks for reading
|
|
|
Post by Ratrouta on Oct 17, 2014 9:30:52 GMT
Hey !!!
On the one hand to tally's mind becoming pretty is an obligation. She thinks that if she does plastic surgery she would become an adult and that the prettiest people look very good so in fact if she doesn't act like this she is a freak and wants to repsect of the supermodel's world.
On the other hand I think that she is doing a big mistake, she doesn't have to obey the rules , and she's too young to have a plastic surgery . She does'nt have the mature and the assurance requiered to choose the great choice. It's possible that she's pretty but in the other town she saw some goergous models and want to be like them .
I agree with Shay point of you which is that she has to be normal and she don't have to lay it a sick therfore she has to be herself and not to act like the other and follow the trend of the models who have a different morphology of the others. As far as I'm concerned, to follow a trend it's quite good but it may take your freedom .
As a conclusion it may be argued that Tally shouldn't become pretty and she has to realise that it's just a trend which is going to change in few time .
|
|